Day 5 – advantages #3 and #4: morality and purpose
If God does not exist, we find no values or commands to turn to which legitimize our conduct. –JEAN-PAUL SARTRE
Theologians often mention two additional advantages of God’s existence. The first is that it gives us moral absolutes, and the second is that it grants us individual and community purpose. The universe of the atheist, in stark contrast, is forever amoral and purposeless.
While I understand these advantages and agree with them, they are not as helpful to me as the two I have already proposed. If I were an atheist, I can imagine myself living what appears to be a "moral" life. Whether I did so because of natural instincts or social practicality, I can see myself behaving as a fairly decent individual, appearing in every respect to be "moral" and "upright." I also can easily imagine, even if I believed in a purposeless world, having what appears to be a worthy purpose or goal for my life. I think I would want to live in a manner that would positively impact those around me and secure for myself a meaningful legacy. If this is not purpose, it's something close to it.
Thus, while only a belief in God yields absolute morality and true purpose, atheism permits at least the appearance of a moral and purposeful life. This is why these last two advantages of God’s existence do not resonate with me as loudly as the others. Life after death and ultimate justice, however, are different matters. Here the atheist has nothing at all to offer and the believer everything. On these two points an honest atheist must concede total advantage.
Daily Quotation
Jean-Paul Sartre, "Existentialism," Existentialism and Human Emotions (trans. Bernard Frechtman; New York: Philosophical Library, 1957), 22.
No comments:
Post a Comment