Day 30 – Point One: life is unfair
This is not fair! This is not just! I shouldn't be graded on the color of the cover but on the content of the paper. –a philosophy student (after writing a research paper on the absence of right and wrong) to his teacher, who gave him an "F" because he didn't like blue covers
I believe it is impossible to go through life without the phrase "That's not fair!" crossing our lips. I know most of us need only replay the past twenty-four hours to note the last time a sense of unfairness entered our minds. My first point in what I call the Argument from Fairness is that everyone has this innate sense that some things are unfair. I believe it is universal, as sure as the sun setting in the west.
Most of you will see rather quickly that I am right. There are some of you, I presume, who may counter that some of history's most evil people were so blind to justice that the thought of fairness and unfairness never entered their minds. The reason they acted so badly, you say, is that no sense of justice was ever a part of them. Think with me a little, and you will see that you are wrong, that even the vilest people this earth has ever known have cried, "That's not fair!”
Take, for example, Adolf Hitler. Although we can never in any way condone the holocaust he inflicted, is it not easy to recognize that he did so in part because his warped mind believed it unfair for Jews to have political and economic advantage over the "superior" Aryan race? When he looked at the world around him, he said, in essence, "That's not fair!" Or take the terrorists who destroyed the Twin Towers and the innocent lives of thousands in the process. Did they not act because they sensed it was not fair for the United States to have such a dominant place in the world? Didn't they also cry, "That's not fair!"? What about the men who conspired to have Jesus crucified? Did they not act on the premise that it was unfair for anyone to make the claims he was making and get away with it? As they heard him speak, they thought, "That's not fair!"
Now I want to make sure that no one misunderstands me. In no shape, form, or fashion am I saying that any of these people were justified in their actions. I am not saying they were right; in fact, I believe they were 100% wrong when they committed these infamous acts. Just because someone thinks he or she has been treated unfairly does not make it a fact. Even if it were, such unfairness does not give anyone license to retaliate with acts of injustice exponentially greater. I’m merely trying to prove to you that evil men and women also consider life unjust. They, like everyone else, have uttered the phrase, "That's not fair!"
Atheists are no exceptions. We have just discussed how they point to sickness, natural calamity, and evil as reasons not to believe in God. In other words, they consider the universe too unjust to have a God behind it. They, in essence, are saying, "That's not fair!"
So it is with the whole of mankind.
Daily Quotation
Steve Kumar, Christianity for Skeptics, 25.
No comments:
Post a Comment